This is a French-issued limited edition version of Patti Smith's last album Trampin, with a bonus live disc thrown in. I'm not going to review the aforementioned album, since there are reviews of this already available elsewhere, but restrict my comments to the bonus disc. Sometimes these bonus discs are a bit of a rip-off, a couple of remixes, b-sides and videos, running time less than 30 minutes. Not in this case. What you get is a full-length CD (72mins 34secs) taken from a French radio broadcast recorded on 24 July 2004. The quality is superb throughout, and if anybody who saw Patti Smith live in 2004 was looking for a great souvenir, they could do worse than start here. OK, "Because the Night", "People have the Power", and "Frederick" aren't on there, but that's a minor quibble. This is a great live recording, and at this point in time, the only officially released Patti Smith live album, so what are you waiting for ? If you've already bought Trampin' buy it again ! If not, why not ? treat yourself now, you won't be disappointed.