I was thrilled to stumble across this in Dress Circle in London today. I thought I had everything of Fred's there was to have but this ravishing collection is a double disc set of delights.
I have treasured the DRG three-disc LP set of the TV special soundtracks for decades. But these remastered versions are a revelation. The sound is excellent throughout, much better than the vinyl, with full, clear fidelity. There are many riches here, highlights including the David Rose/Andre Previn collaboration Young Man With The Blues/Like Young, deliciously moody, the Count Basie Orchestra in ripping form, with elegant banter between The Count and Astaire between numbers; and of course The three famous medleys of Astaire classics, an astounding hit rate of premium standards, all written for this most unlikely of vocal stars. A LOT of people, I find, don't get the Astaire thing and write him off as a vocalist - though no one can be anything but knocked out by his dancing. I have loved him since I was thirteen when I saw Top Hat one Sunday afternoon. In the era of the Bay City Rollers, I was feasting on the greatest of the Great American Songbook.
What makes this CD really special though are the bonus tracks, which will astonish anyone who had wearied of finding the same old out-of-copywrite tracks that get endlessly recycled on Astaire compilations. These are genuinely never-before-issued alternative takes of classic Astaire/Johnny Green sessions from the Swing Time dates, including a brilliant Astaire tap routine on the non-vocal Waltz In Swingtime; and version of A Fine Romance with a surprisingly inelegant verse, that must have been cut after a quick conference, since Astaire does not sound like he is enjoying singing it.
The audio quality on the alternative take of the delightful Nov. 1932 Cole Porter throwaway I've Got You On My Mind is astounding: you almost feel like you are in the studio with them.
There are several other superb bonus tracks from various sources spanning Astaire's career, including a fantastic jazz collaboration from Benny Goodman, The Astaire (1947).
Perhaps the highlight of the whole beguiling collection is a track that should put to rest any doubts about Astaire's supremacy as a vocal stylist: his performance of They Can't Take That Away From Me, from the September 1937 Gershwin Memorial concert. It is powerfully sung in his characteristic unfettered, honest style, a performance whose occasional jarring imperfections make it the one of the most deeply moving, heart-felt, in-the-moment vocal performances ever recorded by anyone.
If there's a quibble, it's that the liner notes give very little useful information about the provenance and restoration of the bonus tracks. It is a real disappointment because the story behind the discovery of these historic recordings surely deserves to be told.
Finally, worth the price of the CD alone is a wonderful photograph of Fred with his life-long friend and alter-ego Hermes Pan, in the rehearsal room for one of the tv specials, both in mid-step, two old-timers doing their thing before a crowd of adoring young chorus dancers.
Thanks to Sepia for this stunning release.