Bette Davis is a great actress and when she plays good, she is good, but when she plays bad, she is even better. `In this Our Life' is a slice of melodrama that sees Davis at her worst; selfish, unlikable, yet still watchable. As Stanley, she is the girl that gets everything she wants, including the husband of her sister Roy. Despite her bad ways the family still stand by her, but will she one day go too far?
Davis is a towering presence in most of her films and has the tendency to overshadow her co-stars, especially the men. However, she does play opposite some great woman and this is the case with Olivia de Havilland, who the plays the put upon Roy, a woman who must grow a harder shell. de Havilland carries the film and is the sympathetic heart and for this reason I actually found her the best thing in it. Davis is good, but her character is so insipid at times that you can't like her; obviously the role she was meant to play. Not many actresses of any era would willingly play such an unlikable specimen, so it is high praise once more for Davis that she takes it on.
`In This' is high melodrama that borders on the impossible and the irrational on occasion, but when you have two great performances at the centre you don't mind a bit of theatrics. One to watch for melodrama fans.