|
Jubilee Offer: Patriotic Classics for £2.50 |
Frequently Bought Together
Product details
|
Track Listings
| 1. The Good Years |
| 2. Sorry |
| 3. Better Things |
| 4. Rivers Run |
| 5. Painted It White |
| 6. Firethief |
| 7. Behind Our |
| 8. Eyes |
| 9. The News |
| 10. Sorrowlessfield |
| 11. Tongue That Cannot Lie |
Product Description
Review
As well as giving birth to her first child, philosophy graduate and folk chanteuse Karine Polwart has somehow found time over the past year to record two new albums, December's traditional Scottish collection, Fairest Floo'er, and now the self-composed This Earthly Spell. Only a full-time musician since the age of 29, Polwart's debut release, Faultlines, won the best album award at the BBC Radio 2 Folk Awards, and since then her simple but evocative style, featuring some stark, often harrowing lyrics inspired both by the history of her native land and her years working for Scottish Women's Aid, have established the Borders-based singer as one of her genre's most respected contemporary exponents.
This Earthly Spell reinforces some of the core elements that forged Polwart's reputation, but does not really deliver much of a punch. Typical tracks like Better Things and Rivers Run carry on the tradition of recently rediscovered female folk greats like Anne Briggs with their prettily meandering acoustic guitar lines and crystal clear vocals, but are little more than proficient and pleasant. Opening number, The Good Years, has the kind of hymnal but slightly saccharine chorus omnipresent in modern country, while The News's pallid jazz evokes unwelcome memories of Fairground Attraction.
It's only on Firethief, a poignant lament to a young man stricken by AIDS, that Polwart really lives up to her reputation as a songwriter of true stature. The hauntingly insistent guitar line and some coruscating imagery combine with powerful effect to describe a mother's ''bonnie laddie'' withering away to become ''a rickle of skin and bone'' - evidence of a captivating storyteller that is rarely apparent elsewhere on This Earthly Spell.
The album closes with the eight minutes plus of Tongue That Cannot Lie, a ponderous elegy to the thirteenth century poet and prophet, Thomas The Rhymer. This medieval sage was no doubt a most intriguing individual, but Polwart is a much more interesting and accessible artist when writing about the struggles of the living. --Chris White
Find more music at the BBC This link will take you off Amazon in a new window
Q (****), April 08
"Rising Scottish folkstress still on the up...spellbinding voice...an exceptionally subtle and melodic songwriter...in a fairer world 'The Good Years' sumptuous harmonies would be all over the airwaves"
Tags Customers Associate with This Product(What's this?)Click on a tag to find related items, discussions, and people.
|
Customer Reviews
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
17 of 17 people found the following review helpful
Format:Audio CD
I only really heard Karine's work for the first time when "Scribbled in Chalk" came out. I listened to the previews of the new album on her myspace page and almost fell off my chair. "Firethief" is powerful and moving especially given the subject matter, "The Good Years" uplifting with it's wonderful melody and vocal harmony and "Sorry" is just too good for words. Actually, there's not a bad song on this. Karine's voice is just perfect, the playing is impeccable, the lyrics are profound and the whole thing made me smile and cry at the same time. I haven't stopped playing it since I bought it. I've already told anyone who will listen that they should buy this album and reward real talent. I'm going to see her in Edinburgh next Sunday and can't wait. Am I gushing? Probably. There's much that is naff about Scottish music but this, currently, is about as good as it gets.
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful
Format:Audio CD
I'd heard of Karine Polwart but never heard her perform until I spent £1.99 on the "That's Proper Folk" CD (or whatever it's called).
Possibly the best £1.99 I've ever spent, if only because it introduced me to this album.
Karine Polwart was head and shoulders the winner on that CD (and I'm a fan of Cara Dillon, so work that one out) with the track "Sorry". Which meant that I had to go out and buy this CD.
Worth every penny: there's clearly a trad-folk element running throughout this, whether it's the tunes or the lyrics, but with a definite modern flavour. Her singing is strong, with her accent a joy to hear (that's one of the great things about folk - no faux American accents), and this is a consistently rewarding album.
If you've come here off the back of the "That's Proper Folk" album, buy this - you won't be disappointed. Now I have to get my wallet out and buy the other albums....
Possibly the best £1.99 I've ever spent, if only because it introduced me to this album.
Karine Polwart was head and shoulders the winner on that CD (and I'm a fan of Cara Dillon, so work that one out) with the track "Sorry". Which meant that I had to go out and buy this CD.
Worth every penny: there's clearly a trad-folk element running throughout this, whether it's the tunes or the lyrics, but with a definite modern flavour. Her singing is strong, with her accent a joy to hear (that's one of the great things about folk - no faux American accents), and this is a consistently rewarding album.
If you've come here off the back of the "That's Proper Folk" album, buy this - you won't be disappointed. Now I have to get my wallet out and buy the other albums....
26 of 28 people found the following review helpful
Format:Audio CD
Karine didn't have a tricky second album. "Scribbled in Chalk" managed to eclipse the impact of her debut solo album "Faultlines", and "Fairest Floor" followed that with equal aplomb, so surely "This Earthly Spell" will finally be a passing work, a mediocrity, proof that no artist can be that consistent. No. Not a bit. Here are 10 songs that would shame any first album with its treasure trove of long saved songs, that both hold together in their totality and yet offer everything from political vitriol to maternal love. A number of songs have had airings on You-Tube as rough recordings but now shine all the brighter for the airy backing vocals of Inge Thomson or the clever rhythms of messers Foulds & McGuire and the ever creative and tasty, tasty perfect simplicity of brother Steven.
This is real, visceral, potent, charming, intimate and profoundly beautiful song writing delivered by an Artist and band of genuine talent and ability which will push every emotional and cerebral button and leave you oddly comforted in it's very existence.
This is real, visceral, potent, charming, intimate and profoundly beautiful song writing delivered by an Artist and band of genuine talent and ability which will push every emotional and cerebral button and leave you oddly comforted in it's very existence.
Would you like to see more reviews about this item?
Were these reviews helpful?
Let us know
Most Recent Customer Reviews
A sublime disc
You don't have to be a fan of trad Scottish folk to enjoy this beautiful album.Regardless of origin or its roots, this is a piece of work that deserves as wide an audience as... Read more
Published 7 months ago by os
Consistently Impressive
This was the first CD of Karine's that I bought, and after a couple of listens immediately bought 'Faultlines' and 'Scribbled In Chalk'. Read more
Published on 13 May 2010 by A. McKenna
Beautiful album
No let up in the quality of K.P's writing arranging and singing.Lyrics sometimes surprising and challenging,sometimes whimsical and touching.
Published on 27 Mar 2010 by TingMart
She weaves a heavenly spell
Like others, I am a big fan of Karine Polwart and, admittedly, biased; but I particularly like this album because her great voice, singing fantastic songs, is complimented by her... Read more
Published on 9 Oct 2009 by Big G
Earthly spellbound
This is a glorious album. The fact that it is different from her previous work should be taken to indicate not a retreat but a development. Read more
Published on 11 Aug 2009 by R. A. Johnson
An incredible talent
First up a confession, I am huge fan of Karine. I really think she has something special in terms of musical talent, however if you are going to review a record it is only fair to... Read more
Published on 15 May 2009 by Mr. N. J. Harding
another great album
on a par with kate rusby, alison krauss , etc - why are there so many more auperb female singers than male singers? the reverse of tennis - is there a connection?
Published on 14 May 2009 by Philip Chadwick
Regardless of its genre, this is music of the highest order
Karine Polwart was recommended to me by a friend; having never heard of her, I took a chance and bought this album just before Christmas - I have not regretted doing so. Read more
Published on 31 Dec 2008 by S. Higgens
Edgy 4th album - take time to listen!
Songs on this album are more edgy than Karine's earlier work and take a bit more listening to but are very much worth it. Personal favourites are Sorry and Rivers Run. Read more
Published on 8 Oct 2008 by Steve M.
What a find!!!
Faultless!
Buy this one, and then buy them all. You'll not be disappointed.
Buy this one, and then buy them all. You'll not be disappointed.
Published on 25 Aug 2008 by soreleftfoot
Customer Discussions
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|
What Other Items Do Customers Buy After Viewing This Item?
Listmania!
|
|
Look for similar items by category
Look for similar items by subject
Feedback
- Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
