An improvement on 'Extra Texture' for sure. And the best thing to report on this album is that we hear much more of that unique Harrison slide guitar so absent from the previous two albums. And secondly that the album maintains a positive uplifting mood throughout, a massive contrast to the last outing. A trend that was to continue on the next album 'George Harrison' (1979). But the difference between this and the next album is in the songwriting, so consitently melodic and brilliant on the latter, and so uneven here really. In truth this is a 3 and half star album and the only reason I have rounded it up as opposed to down is because of the numerous outstanding guitar solos and because George had dragged himself out of the pit of depression he seemed to be in on the previous album 'Extra Texture'.
OK let's get to the songwriting which probably ultimately dictates how often we return to listen to an album. There is at least one outstanding track 'Learning How To Love You', a tender moving ballad which brings the album to a serene and relaxing finish. There were even two minor hit singles, quite a rarity for George post 1973: 'This Song' and 'Crackerbox Palace'. Both catchy and inoffensive on first listen. But after repeated listenings they become pretty tiresome and show themselves to be what they mostly are. Lightweight.
There is one track 'See Yourself' which had been started in 1967 in response to when McCartney admitted to the press that he had taken LSD. He didn't finish until now nine years later. No big surprise but although it's lyrically quite interesting, as a melody it's pretty mediocre. 'It's What You Value' and 'Woman Don't You Cry For Me' are both cheerful good sounding songs taken to a higher level than they might have been by the superb musicianship, especially George's superb slide on 'Woman'. As songs they are better than mediocre, but not by too much.
'True Smokey' is another meandering dirge to Smokey Robinson, like the one on 'Extra Texture'. Boring.
The other two songs which I've not discussed are probably the best, excepting 'Learning How To Love You'. 'True Love' covers the Cole Porter classic in confident style and the guitar hear makes it about ten times better than the original if you ask me. Trust no Cole Porter fan is reading this.:-). The second track 'Dear One' is a heartfelt plea and thank you to Harrison's God. Good melody, interesting arrangement and a very sincere and moving set of lyrics. Then there is 'Beautiful Girl', the first of many truly great songs George would write for his Olivia. Although this one in particular probably achieves great status on account of the wonderful slide work.
So this is a mixed bag of Harrison goodies and not so goodies. It paves the way for the triumphant next album 'George Harrison' but lacks that songwriting quality which was so obvious there but which then somewhat deserted him again on the next two albums after that one, 'Somewhere In England' (1981) and 'Gone Troppo' (1982). Another review or two!
For mood, style and guitar this is probably a 5 star album. But for songwriting it is not much better than a 3 if we're honest.