The well deserved winner of the 2005 Boardman Tasker Award was Andy Cave's `Learning To Breathe'. This second book, 'Thin White Line', was entered for the 2008 Award but did not make the short-list - and I believe this is fair judgement. The first was effortlessly autobiographical from childhood to Changabang and it was truly an extraordinary odyssey. `Thin White Line' follows on from the tragedy of Changabang and it sensitively deals with Andy Cave's rehabilitation to hard climbing and serious mountaineering. It is well written, candid and humorous, but narrative flows in uneven and less structured manner. There are unique descriptions of fears and thoughtful explanations on risks; and there is no doubting the awesome technical competency of Andy Cave and his climbing companions, but however dramatic and dangerous their exploits the book is basically a chronicle of meanderings through Britain, Patagonia, Norway and Yukon in similar style to many other stories of events and epics in the mountains. `Thin White Line' remains a good book - but it is an ordinary odyssey and not an extraordinary book as `Learning To Breathe'.