This was the first of the World Book Day Quick Reads I read. And while it's a great tale, and fulfills the brief of being an engaging and gripping story written in simple language, it's also the weakest. (Let's put this in perspective a bit more, though: I've read two. None of the others appealed to me whatsoever; probably a good thing: it shows that there's a huge range of titles across the board, and that at least one is going to appeal to someone.) So, of the two I've read (the Walters being the other (that one was superb), I didn't find Rendell's as strong. Normally, Rendell's short pieces (particularly her novels, such as The Strawberry Tree and High Mysterious Union) are among her absolute best work, allowing a wonderful union of her direct, clipped style and her ability to focus plots and characters brilliantly, but this tale, which does succeed in being incredibly interesting and still entertaining, lacks a punch. It's almost Rendell-lite. It wasn't quite what i'd expected from the blurb, certainly. I did get an enjoyable read, but it just wasn't what i'd expected, that's all. Rendell's analysis of Polly is, as expected, excelllent, and Polly's little compulsion is pure Rendell. It's the kind of fascinating foible that makes her characters fascinate as much as thin twisted trees. Rendell just doesn't use it in quite her usual way, that's all.
The Thief has a brilliant premise, and if Rendell had thrown in a little bit more nastiness, it would have made an absolutely perfect novel. As it is, it's a quick, enjoyable, really easy to read story, and one that I'm sure people will enjoy. It may not be quite what I'd expected , but it still gets five stars. And that's Rendell in a nutshell.