Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A very good book, respectful both of facts and of myths, 8 Feb 2008
I really liked this Osprey Campaign book. This battle is so famous that we always tend to believe that we know all the facts about it - and of course we are wrong. I learned a lot from this book and maybe for the first time I really clearly understood what were the sources of superiority of Greek hoplits when facing huge Persian armies. Nic Fields explained very well his point, describing the fight between a close combat army (Greeks) against a distance combat army (Persians). It is clear that when the latter was forced to fight on ennemies terms, it would suffer greatly, even if at the end the numbers would make the decision. Important points are well described, like the poor performance of Greek troops covering the mountainous track, which failed to stop or even delay advancing "Immortals". Nic Fields claims also and proves, that Leonidas decision that the rearguard must stay and fight rather than escape, was tactically very sound and allowed most of the Greek army to retire and fight another day - namely in victorious and decisive battle of Plataea in 479...
This book is very clearly written and is a very easy and pleasant read. Illustrations are excellent, however, the colour plates are slightly less good that I expected. Steve Noon is possibly the most talented Osprey illustrator when modern wars are concerned - but here, in the ancient warfare he seems to be less comfortable. I do not know why, but all the books about Greek Persian wars seem to be victims of a curse affecting the illustrations (just remember the horrible Osprey Elite issue about armies of Ancient Persia!!). Here the three colour plates are not bad, but could definitely be better. Still, this doesn't affect my rating. Five stars, well deserved, and I will be looking forward for the next Nic Fields book - why not "Salamis 480 BC"?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Brilliant Introduction to this Legendary Battle, 25 July 2008
In this short book, Nic Fields presents us with a look at the Battle of Thermopylae in 480 BC, the battle that delayed the Persian army and saved Greece.
Yet, there is more to this book than simply a description of this famous event. Fields covers the 'before, during, and after' stages of the battle, explaining to the reader the origins of the campaign as well as its conclusion with the defeat of Mardonios's army at Plataea in 479 BC.
He presents us with short biographies of the commanders of both sides, covering Leonidas of Sparta and the Great Persian king, Xerxes. He also explains to the reader the equipment and fighting techniques of the Greek and Persian armies, explaining how they differed and how this would ultimately be the deciding factor of the campaign.
With the background explained, as well as the Greek and Persian plans layed out, Fields then details the events of the battle. He is assisted by three wonderful 3D bird's eye-view maps that cover the differnt stages of the battle. These aren't as detailed as some of the maps contained in other Osprey Campaign titles, but that's more to do with the lack of notable sites on the battle terrain. Steve Noon provides three terrific colour plates, showing the Persian scout spying on the Spartans at rest while the other two plates show the Greeks and Persians in battle. These are generally very good, and the detail is crisp rather than the typically muddy illustrations that are usually thrown together for Osprey Campaign titles.
With plenty of maps, photographs of the modern battlefield and archaeological finds, as well as diagrams and a bibliography, this book should be the standard introduction to this legendary battle. That said, it shouldn't be the only book you read on the subject as there are other more in-depth and scholarly works available. If it had one fault, it is that only a few pages of the book actually cover the battle, but I suppose this is because of the lack of written sources beyond Herodotus's account.
I have to say that I found this book an eye opener. It dismisses some of the more bombastic statements made about the battle, explaining that it was far more than 300 Spartans who made tha last stand, as their helot servants, the Thespian Hoplites and the Thebans were all there with Leonidas on the last day as Xerxes troops surrounded them, even if the Thebans did surrender.
A good introductory title.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
1 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
One of the best written books in the series, 10 Jan 2008
Nic Fields ought to be congratulated for this book. I started reading it and simply could not put it down, it reads almost as well as a novel. The key fact that he challenges some of the acquired notions about this battle makes this a fascinating read: the Persians were far from being Barbarians, they were not a poorly equipped and poorly trained fighting force and most importantly the Spartans were not the only Greek contingent fighting this battle.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
|