"Surprisingly good, as is the whole trilogy, well written, clever, Pullman creates a wonderful image. Don't be put off by the 'Childish' theme- a sophisticated novel."
"Yes, yes, not very original I know. If you are a first timer to Tolkein, however, then I would recommend the audio tapes done by the BBC, which are excellent ( ISBN: 0563388129)"
"Very, Very good- written at a fast pace, reminiscent of his Sharpe novels, good action, reasonably clever, good fun to read- Suspence is high at the end."
