The burning question is, quite obviously, whether "The Crucible of Man", with Iced Earth's most loved vocalist Matt Barlow, beats the previous offering from the band, "Framing Armageddon" with Tim "Ripper" Owens. The answer is, perhaps obviously, too: It depends. If you're one of those fans who couldn't stand the voice of Owens but liked the music on "Framing Armageddon", you'll adore "The Crucible of Man", which is mostly similar to its predecessor, but with some catchier tunes ("Divide and Devour" is a bona fide killer!), and Barlow's voice fits the material just perfectly. If, however, you didn't mind Owens singing on "FA" (he's a talented vocalist, no doubt about that), but you found the music a bit "watered down" in comparison with Iced Earth's earlier albums, you'll probably like "TCOM" only a bit more - it's tighter and more melodic, sure, but it definitely isn't as crazy and fast as some of the band's classics.
Still, though - "The Crucible of Man" is a very good album and certainly an improvement over "Framing Armageddon". Listen to such tracks as "Behold the Wicked Child", "A Gift or a Curse", "Harbinger of Fate" or the already mentioned "Divide and Devour", and you'll realize Iced Earth can still do their job.