I was thrilled to see two such different reviews for this lovely book. I don't happen to agree with the negative one but what it really tells you, read alongside the positive alternative, is that Elspeth Thompson's ideas are real, varied and challenging as well as cosy and affirmative. The book looks really pretty on the outside - a great bonus if you're thinking of it as a Christmas present - but once you get into it you may be surprised. I bought a copy at a signing event, took it home and dipped into it from time to time. The more I did this the more treasures I found. I'm definitely going to try some of these ideas for myself, save some money, try to be a better guest, hostess, take more walks, learn a new skill, it's all money-saving, life-affirming and positive. I'm giving five copies away for Christmas - but keeping the original for myself!