I was extremely disappointed by this book. I have read all the others in the series and I really liked them - unfortunately, this weighty volume has rather spoiled it. The language is SO over the top - and how many times do we have to be told that Arithon has black hair and green eyes and Lysaer has blue eyes and blonde hair? I for one am sick of hearing the same old descriptions trotted out in ever more flowery and hyperbolic ways. Similarly, I'm getting pretty sick of Arithon and his compassion. I'm sure it's all very nice, but frankly, I've had more than enough of it. He's become extraordinarily irritating. Why do we have to put up with hearing about his endless bouts of emotional agony and self-blame? Someone should really give him a slap and tell him to pull himself together. He's become a character who wallows in pessimism and self-pity. Lysaer becomes increasingly repulsive - his treatment of his wife is despicable, and hey, how long will it be before little Kevor notices and goes over to Arithon's side? Sorry Janny, I used to love your characters, I used to care about them. Unfortunately, they've become more like caricatures than real people and I've had enough of their misery. The depressing thing is that there is NO HOPE. In the very first book we're told that the Wars of Light and Shadow go on for 500 years. So Arithon's not going to find the Paravians, the whole debacle is never going to be sorted out, instead we're going to get an endless parade of tragedy and misery. Anyway, doesn't the Black Rose prophecy state that the paravians won't be found until Arithon's been crowned King of Rathain? Who knows? At this stage, frankly, who cares?