At the beginning of this book I had several jaw dropping moments, hearing some one describe perfectly how my life had developed as a gay man from childhood in a generally homophobic world, and what was the source of my internal rage that I had endured throughout my life. 'The little boy with the big secret' as he so perfectly described it. Even the title of the book spoke to me, having harboured an unknown anger all my life that I was keen to make sense of. I was so keen to read on and hear what he had to say. I had read reviews before reading it saying that the book was indeed life changing. It certainly gave me that impression in the first few chapters that it might well be. But as the book progressed it all seemed so one dimensional. It assumed that all gay men are obsessive careerists, with perfect bodies, or the desire to have perfect bodies. Where I wondered was the advice for the less than perfectionist gay, the ones who might be over weight or who have no clue how to dress themselves or style a home. I suspect they would have only become further alienated by this book. As indeed would the people who don't flit from lover to lover, and aren't youth obsessed.
There is a distinct cultural difference between American gay men and european ones, even though there are global similarities obviously. And this is a very American book, which is directed towards American gay men. I do think that there is an increased obsession with success in the USA, that you don't find so much certainly here in the UK, and that is reflected here.
I read on through the book as he went on to highlight our failings as gay adults, and what was the cause of them, I felt that he offered little in way of solution. All I really gained from the book was that I probably needed therapy as a result of my Velvet Rage, but then he is a therapist.
I think this book will benefit some people, but it doesn't go across the board to speak to every (gay) man, as I had thought it might with such a promising start.