First a warning. If you are looking for state of the art recordings and performances, this is not the set for you. You would be better to buy some of the recent recordings of todays great choirs, easily found on labels such as Hyperion and Regent etc. Nevertheless, as someone who grew up in the 60's and acquired my love of church music at this time, I found these recordings revelatory! There were some real surprises. St.Pauls were just as I remembered them before Barry Rose( followed admirably by John Scott)turned them into a wonderful choir. I used to attend evensong(in the 60's) and hear solid, dependable performances of standard repertoire. This is what we get here,with the recordings showing their age. Westminster Abbey comes off much better( much to my surprise). Check out Simon Preston letting rip in "Salvator Mundi" No-one would dare to do that these days.
I know the Guildford recording well, having sung in the choir in the late 60,s. It clearly shows a fantastic choir in the making, not quite there yet but well on the way. "Thou Knowest Lord" is beautifully sung.However, the singing which really made me sit up came from Chichester. What a wonderful choir! The boys sing with that lovely pure English tone which is now unfashionable and the musicality and ensemble of the choir is near perfect.At the time these recordings were made,Kings and Johns at Cambridge were busy setting new standards of performance and these discs show clearly who was listening. Obviously John Birch and Barry Rose!
There are other delights in this set.The sadly missed boys from All Saints, Margaret St. sing beautifully, while the choir from Hampstead Parish Church show where Barry Rose got his inspiration. Most remarkable of all, the recordings from the Temple Church hark back to an older generation. Is it my imagination, but do they sound a little like present day New College Oxford !