After a dissapointing start with the Elder Gods, I was prepared to give the series another chance. I loved all of Edding's previous series, especially the Sparhawk books, but I really feel that these books don't even come close to the quality Edding fans should expect. Don't get me wrong - it's a good book.
The Eddings retain their dry humour, and frequently amusing conversation - although some phrases are repeated too often, and it begins to stand out. The pace is great as usual, and the books moves along fast enough to hold your attention, and the authors handle passage of time very well, and always accord each event with the right amount of attention. But it deosn't feel as mature as the last ones, and seems to be a book more aimed at children with the writing style and characters employed. And some of the events and plans are a little to elaborate and far-fetched (I mean, come on - a desert of fake gold?) A problem Eddings has with characters is the female ones - they are always very similar in one way or the other! Its not so noticeable in the other books, but it is in these. Woman are always smart, secretive, make 'clever' remarks, are usually quite condescending to men. I asure you - if you look you will find most of these traits in nine out of ten female characters. The male characters are much better, although some of them are too constantly good, clever, honest (insert good virtues here) to be real or to be able to empathise with. To be honest I though some of the evil characters were much better than the good ones, but the bitter commander Narasan is a good character as well.
The book is good, and I am still looking forwards to the third one, but I really feel this series is a dissapointment. If you are a new Eddings reader, take my advice and read the Belgariad or the Elenium first - some of the best books I have read.