This is the third in the Fethering mystery series and I come to it having read, the two before but also some of the other books afterwards.
The main protagonists are back, neighbours in Fethering, Carole Seddon and Jude? (There are a couple of clues in this book to the possibility of her surname). The premise is the same, a body is discovered by one of the two sleuthing neighbours, they seek to find out what happened and whodunit, and inevitably one of the gets caught up in the tangled web of mystery whilst the other works it all out and comes to her rescue.
A torso is found in the cellar of a local Fedborough house, but how long has it been there and what is the connection with the previous residents and some of the local people? The town is described by Simon Brett well, and he encapsulates all of the key places in the area as well as showing us a town very much divided by class. Key characters, the local architect, the ex butcher, the interior designer, the vicar, the doctor and his wife, the token aristocrat as well as the less 'well to do' are all featured, and means that Carole and Jude have a lot of ground to cover in finding out information, but everyone is so helpful, that it becomes suspicious. After a couple of red herrings, the answer is not all it seems to be and it tests both faith and morals.
In my opinion this is a rather weak story, compared to the others which are far better. Do not start with this one if you have never read any Brett's Fethering mysteries before, it will leave you disappointed. I felt it needed a bit more substance and I found myself drifting off from the actual plot too many times, as I wondered on what local town, Brett had based Fedborough on. However, to glean something from this book and my review, Brett has managed to keep us the readers and Carole guessing about Jude's background - to the point of frustration. This remains the long running mystery throughout these books - Jude. If we find out about her though, will it mark the end of their partnership and the Fethering mysteries for us?