One of my 2004 reviews not uploaded at the time to amazon.co.uk
***
Comisario Miguel Fortunato has a face that makes him ideal for the work that he does. No one could ever imagine that this kindly, respectful looking middle aged man could be lying to them, or would do anything to harm. The Buenos Aires police department have their uses for such a man.
Fortunato is no different from his colleagues in that a large portion of his time is spent trying to contain the crime that is rampant in the city. That containment is control, and from that control and position of power it is the habit of the police to extort money from the criminals that they investigate. It is not done purely to supplement their salaries; they must reinforce the opinion that the police should never be underestimated or left in the dark. Who has the real control? The criminals or the criminals in uniform employed by the people?
When an American writer is killed in Buenos Aires a human rights professor is sent from the U.S. to seek answers on behalf of the deceased's family. Athena Fowler is young and fresh out of college with her ideals still intact. Under the wing of the kindly Fortunato she is aware that she is being manipulated to see a little, write a little, and go home. Her new friend is saddened by what he must do in order to protect his employers - the same people that once ordered him to kill for reasons he now knows to be false.
The sultry, brooding sense of menace that is portrayed in "The Stone Angels" is masterfully done, making a whole character out of the one city with millions of citizens. The sense of despair is that things will never change and the inherent corruption will always be so, to the frustration of so many. All the passion and the anger, the realization of betrayal with its subsequent retribution contained in the music and the dance of the tango is carried through the storyline as a beating pulse that never lets up. It's too heavy though, and what fails in this novel is that you have a whole pile of two-faced characters that you really care little for. There is no real fall of grace, as they were all ready in the pits to begin with. Droning narratives and clumsy characterization take the sparkle off "The Stone Angels" which could have been so much more with some fine tuning and greater attention given to the creation of rounded, believable leads. An author to watch.