This book is well researched and full of historical anecdotes and other interesting background information, which adds to the interest of the walk.
However, it is not a book for backpackers as it is far to0 heavy and difficult to use.
It could have been designed better in my opinion. The walk instructions are muddled in with all the other blurb, and soaking, wind swept walkers who have lost their way will spend ages quivering in the storm as they read through pages trying to locate the instructions they need.
The maps are useful but there is no cross reference numbering to instantly locate the instructions in the book with the location on the map; a surprising omission, as every other national trail guide I have has this simple and excellent facility. Admittedly the publisher, Aurum Press, is different for the other books. Aurum also include map sections on the pages which works very well for quick navigation. Sadly, The official guide book has no map sections within it, leading to awkward fumbling with the big, fold-out maps and cross reading with the book. The maps are good, but you need the route in the book too, in my opinion.
The book has an identity problem. It includes details on short walks as well as the whole trail and as such doesn't know what market it is aiming for. It's trying to be all things to everyone, and as such, ends up being no good for long-distance back-packers. This is a book most suited to day walkers who don't have lots of other gear to carry, I reckon.
I've bought the Cicerone guide, as well, now (which isn't perfect either, but is lighter), and plan to take it, and the maps from the official guide when I do the SUW. One small niggle with the maps is that there is no scale printed on them for quick thumb estimates of distance. We know the scale of the map, but I've got to draw my own '4 miles is this long' line on it before I go!
How I wish that there was an up-to-date Aurum guide for this walk. Aurum has the long distance walker in mind and strikes the right balance between weight and content. Their books have rounded corners to prevent excessive back-pack ware, instructions referenced to map sections within the book and a clear and easily usable layout.
Anthony Burton's Aurum book is now 14 years old, and although designed to work well, may be incorrect in some parts due to route changes (perhaps others could comment). I used Anthony Burton's book six years ago and found it easy to use but light on background information (unusual for Aurum, and perhaps due to weight constraints and the length of the walk).
Seems to me that whichever book is bought for this walk, just now, a measure of compromise is involved.
UC