Joe Simpson is well known for his none fiction writing about mountaineering, so much so that he (or his publishers) felt the need to add "A Novel" to the title of this book. This is an important point, for while Simpson has published a novel in the past, fiction writing has not really help to build his deserved reputation as a writer.
So readers need to be prepared for this change of direction.
The second thing that many people may find surprising is that this novel is a love story. It's about the love of a woman lost, a love refound and, ever present in the background, the love of the mountains.
The open pages of this book are remarkable - and it's probably worth reading the whole book just to find out where the such a remarkable beginning ends. Some reviews have suggested that the first section of the book - revolving around a death and a desperate descent from a mountain - it too long, too detailed and too slow. I disagree - this is what Simpson knows best, and the detail along with the compression and expansion of time in this section of the book clearly has the ring of experience to it.
The second half of the book - set 25 years after the first - sees the development of the more standard (and possibly predictable) section of the book. Simpson does not shy away from showing mountaineers as less than noble, and I think it is this feeling of realism that saves this section of the book from sentimentality.
At their heart the best mountaineering books are about the relationship between the climber and the mountain. The parallels to human relationships are clear - obsession, passion and risk all play a role in both mountaineering and love. And it may not be a coincidence that exposed or poorly protected sections of climbs are known as `committing'. Once you commit, your life may never be the same.
I don't think this book is destined to become a classic, but it is an interesting exploration of the links that can form between people and mountains.
If you want a book that explores the details of climbing routes and gear placements, this will not be the book for you.
If, on the other hand, you want to read a book that explores a different aspect of mountaineering - the way that the mountains can come to mean so much more than just a physical challenge - then this book may be for you.
Recommended.