It's admittedly hard for me to come to terms with the fact that while I am ecstatic about one of my all time favorite artists finally getting his back catalog issued on CD, I am not thrilled with the effort being put into them thus far.
But I should probably start with the music first.
Any fan of Smokey's solo career is probably most familiar with "Quiet Storm". It's considered his seminal solo album. I for one, have never rated this album very highly. It's certainly good, but doesn't contain many of my favorite Smokey tunes. The first three tracks are on most compilation albums that have been released over the years. And of the remaining four, I would probably only rate "Coincidentally" as a very strong tune. In particular, "Wedding Song" and "Happy" just don't speak to me on a regular basis.
Smokey's Family Robinson on the other hand is a virtual masterpiece. In the liner notes, Smokey apparently felt this album was recorded poorly (it was the first in his new home studio), and I simply could not disagree more. I love the borderline unpolished production of this album. The opening track "When You Came" has a lot of energy. And that electric cello solo is so "Un-Smokey", it's absolutely fantastic. Speaking of Un-Smokey, how about the sheer funk of "Like I Do"? It's album track songs like this that have remained unheard for far too long. What a killer track. The last two mellow songs "Like Nobody Can" and "Castles Made of Sand" are two more prime examples of how Smokey can write, (and sing) a hauntingly beautiful, original song. Unlike Quiet Storm, Smokey's Family Robinson has no weak moments for me personally.
There is a bonus track from a long out of print soundtrack that doesn't do much for me, even though I'm very grateful for its' inclusion.
Like my review of the first rerelease, I am a bit disappointed with some of things that have not been included. In a 20 some odd page booklet, yet again, there are no lyrics. Come on, Smokey is just as famous for his brilliant words as he is anything else. Their omission is very disappointing. And the writer of the booklet's liner notes, while obviously a Smokey fan, doesn't really provide much in depth material. Smokey was interviewed specifically for this rerelease series, yet the inspiration behind so many tracks get left out again. Seeing that this is probably the one and only chance this material is going to get released during my lifetime, I just feel like it could/should have been done better.
Like the first time around, I don't want to lead anyone astray. Please support this music. It is timeless and extremely worthy of being purchased. Bravo for Hip-O and Smokey. But as a "product review", I feel compelled to inform that I expected/hoped for a bit more than what we have been receiving thus far. And seeing that volume three was set up the exact same way, I fear that is going to be my underlying theme throughout this series.