To lovers of historical novels like myself, the story of 'the sixth wife', Katherine Parr, is a familiar one.
This was the wife who nursed Henry VIII through his final years and survived his death, who married Thomas Seymour (presumably for love) almost immediately afterwards, only to die in childbirth the following year.
Suzannah Dunn has attempted a new twist by throwing another real-life character into this story - Catherine, Duchess of Suffolk, young widow of Henry's best friend - and inventing a love affair between her and Seymour which contributed to his downfall (rather than the rumoured affair with Princess Elizabeth).
Unfortunately it doesn't come off at all.
Mainly because the above premise is the whole plot - there's nothing more to it. She offers no new insights or revelations, there's no evidence of any research, no attempt to recreate the atmosphere of the times. It's such a waffly, repetitive and lazy effort. Her attempts at updating the dialogue are jarring, even laughable: it's one thing to avoid 'Tudorspeak', but quite another to go as far as 'You look fabulous'! And would they really refer to the young king as 'Eddie'?
Making Duchess Cathy the narrator didn't help, either. She's such a dull, unpleasant and unconvincing creation, and it's all about her. Yet by the end I still couldn't pick her out of a crowd - she could be anyone, in any period of history. None of her relationships ring true: she tells us how much she loves her sons and her best friend Kate, but she doesn't show us. The childbirth death scene left her completely cold, along with this reader. Dunn should try reading some Sharon Penman to get a few tips.
There are so many other novels set in this period to choose from, don't bother with this one - even Philippa Gregory does it better. Or try Alison Weir. Even Jean Plaidy. Or if romance isn't your thing, there's a very good portrait of Katherine Parr in C J Sansom's
Revelation (Shardlake).
Anything but this, in fact.