This is the latest volume in the Simon & Kirby Library, reprinting 32 stories from titles published from 1947-49, and 2 from 1954 & 1955, for a total of 299 pages of comics. The titles are Clue Comics 1947 (4 stories), Real Clue Crime Stories 1947 (6), headline Comics 1947-48 (13), Justice Traps the Guilty 1947-49 (9), and one each from Police Trap #2 and #6, 1954 & 1955. There is also a cover gallery of 13 covers, one of which is a photo-cover featuring Jack Kirby as a nervous-looking safecracker facing Joe Simon's police revolver.
The stories range from 4 to 15 pages, but are mainly longer rather than shorter. Although set mainly in the `gangster' era, there are a couple of historical stories, and a couple set in Europe. Some are `true' stories and many are pure fiction - Max Allan Collins describes one of the `true' stories in his Introduction as being a `flirtation with fact'. Also, as Mr Collins notes, although dealing with crime, some of the stories are from other genres; there is a western, a couple of historical, and several are written in the `true romance' format, though also featuring machine guns. Of the `historical' (in relation to the 1940s that is, not just to us today) - one is the story of Guy Fawkes, which is actually quite accurate, despite being rather more melodramatic than was actually the case - but this is a comic-book! (Thinks... Mel Gibson as Guy Fawkes - misunderstood war hero who tries to save England - and Scotland - for the Catholic church, but ends up being tortured and executed for his courage in challenging the Evil British Empire...) Some stories are in theory documentary - but Joe & Jack manage to make them stand out from the drab stories of `Crime Does Not Pay' - see Blackjacked and Pistol-Whipped: The Best of Crime Does Not Pay for examples of those; here however, in "Gang Doctor" for example, a 7-page story, the second page, comprising six panels, is given over to a bank clerk on his first day at the job, who is shot by Dillinger in the final panel of the page. In the ensuing robbery, one of Dillinger's men is shot, and the services of the titular Gang Doctor is thus required, leading us on in to the main story. That page of the bank clerk was not relevant to the plot (and could be construed as filler by the uncharitable), but it `worked', and it showed Simon & Kirby adding that extra touch to the story that lifted their work above so many of their contemporaries.
Note that Dark Horse are going to produce an Archive series of `Crime Does Not Pay' - I recommend you check the `Best of' referenced above and compare the stories in this volume. I gave it 5-stars in my review, which it deserved for what it was, but this book is worth 15 stars by comparison. I will still be buying the Dark Horse series, because I collect stuff, but Simon & Kirby are the undoubted Kings of Crime.