I don't know why I view Adrian Tchaikovsky's Shadows of the Apt as guilty pleasure, given that the stories have well crafted characters, thrilling plots and some stunning battles. I think it was the initial premise - people with some insect-derived powers - that seemed a little twee. Plus the fact that there were spiders too, a move surely designed to callously enrage entomological pedants everywhere.
With the Sea Watch, the initial insect focus becomes even more awry, with the revelation of an entirely new category of kinden - no surprises for guessing where they come from. After the events in the Scarab Path we return to Collegium, where Stenwold Maker is trying to prepare for the inevitable resumption of hostilities with the Wasp Empire, whilst avoiding a war between supposed allies in Tsen and Vek. And while he does, ships keep on disappearing...
This is a book of three halves, and the initial part, as Stenwold slowly descriptions the mystery of the vanishing ships, I though was gripping We are treated to some new characters, and I liked the Fly Laszlo. There are some stunning developments with Teornis the spider savior of Collegium during the Vekken war and Arianna, Stenwold's lover. One of the strengths of this book is that we get a much better insight in to the spider mindset, and these two characters really come alive in this book. The second part of the book - I cannot say much without giving much of the plot away - I found tended to drag. The descriptions of the new Sea-Kinden are good and as ever the abilities and synergy between creature and kinden are well thought out, but as we are literally flooded with new information the plot itself tends to grind to a halt. This is one example where multiple plot stands would have been better as the lengthy descriptions could have been interspersed with more action. Fortunately things pick up in the final third of the book, and we get some more trademark Tchaikovsky battles and plot twists.
The Sea Watch is therefore a solid 4 star book and I have to say I am amazed at the speed the Apt books are turned out, given the quality of the writing. Roll on the next...