This book was, and is, excellent. I'm always very weary of giving anything a perfect score (after all, what is perfect?), but there was no 4.75, so a 5/5 will have to do. I actually read 'The Scholar' 2 years after reading 'Society Within' (which I studied for A level), then I read the reviews on this site; the majority stating that 'The Scholar' was much better. I enjoyed both books, as they deal with an aspect of life in the UK hardly ever really sufficiently represented on television, let alone in text. 'Society Within' draws you into the marginalised societies that not only the young characters are living in, but also young people today, right under our own noses: "A world inside another world, operatin' with its own rules and regulations, its own terms and understandin's" (p.132). Reading it, also allowed me to reflect upon the dialect used by the (mainly black) characters, often seen as substandard in our society, yet Newland forces it upon the reader; if you want to understand and enjoy this book, you have to also make the effort to see their dialect as standard. It commands respect. In addition, I enjoyed the love-story in 'Society Within', as well as the mixture of harsh, and at times vile, occurrences on the Greenside Estate.
Still, most of the events that occur in 'The Scholar' are much more harsh, which is one of the reasons why I feel some people prefer Newland's first novel. He's less sympathetic to the reader. At times a simple reflection of life itself, to the extent that I found myself so emotionally involved, so caught up in the fast-paced, manic nature of the events that sometimes all I could do was read and read, whilst at others I was too afraid of what the next page/paragraph would bring. It took me 3-4days to read the last 20 pages, simply because I was so scared that I knew how it would end. I was wrong. In fact, I think that happened a lot in this novel; Newland is so hard to predict. I liked that though- it meant I was never bored. Even the ending had me reaching for my 'Society Within' book, simply so that I could try & piece together what happened next to Sean & Cory, but there still wasn't enough information!!
MR. NEWLAND: PLEASE WRITE A SCRIPT!!! The world of movies needs writers such as yourself! If you don't, you may well get a letter from me a few years from now stating that I've HAD to turn your novels into a script.. Haha!
Both books are excellent, and to some degree Newland writes them with different styles, so why not simply get them both. That is... if you can stomach it. x