Like the other Rough Guides to cinema, this one seems to be an able introduction with a lot of amusing sidebars - such as a guide to Italian recipes as presented in gangster flicks. The discordant note: inattentive editing. Time after time, I came across minor errors: for example, Larry Cohen's film Original Gangstas is wrongly titled Old Gangstas. We are also told that Luca Brasi gives a recipe for pasta sauce in The Godfather. In fact, the scene involves Clemenza; by that point in the movie, Luca Brasi is already sleeping with the fishes. . . Sure, these are minor points. But one inevitably suspects that there may be more important slips that one hasn't noticed.