This review covers all four books. The first thing I noticed was the stakes increased from each book to the next. Book one essentially evolved around a plot to remove a single poet from a single city. Book two focuses on a central characters rise to ruling a city. Book 3 involves a fight to save an entire country or collection of cities. Book 4 involves a plot to save 2 nations from complete anihilation. The books are character driven but increase in plot intensity from one book to the next. The plot holes in book one seem to not appear in books 2-4 as the writer's skill increases.
The series is aplty named: The Long Price. The focus is on the price poets pay to control andants (essentially the only magic or fantasy element in these stories). There is a price of power and it is always related to the poet themselves. Essentially they cannot create this power with also creating their own price they must pay. But the price of decisions is carried on as a theme for all characters and all decisions. The decision to love someone and betray a friend has a price carried through all the novels. The decision to love someone and not take other wives has a price. The deicision to abandon being a husband and father has a price. The decision to strive for peace has a cost as does the decision to forgoe peace and seek unilateral victory. Over and over characters make decisions and the novels chronicle the cost of their decisions. In this, the novel is deep, character driven, and realistic.
The other thing I noted is that this is minimally fantasy. In other words, there is very little magic (limited to the andants), no non-human characters, no strange worlds. I dont say this as a critique. The author focus on a real world of politics, intrigue, and mercantilism. Armies cant feed themselves without farmers. Rulers cant have wealth without merchants being successful. The books recognize this and are very realistic in their writing.
The author also avoids fantasy tropes of good and evil characters. In the veins of GRR Martin, Glen Cook, Joe Ambercrombie, ect, ect... the characters here are not good and not bad. They are human and as such motivated to protect and advance themselves. The difference here is that most of these characters fall closer on the scale to good. If Martins characters are grey to black, Abrahams are grey to white. I actually found this refreshing, to see characters closer to the world I live in.
The last point, for a man, Mr Abraham writes women well. They are intuitive, strong, vulnerable, loving, intelligent, beautiful. So many fantasy writers seem to write women into boxes. The women who exist only for sex. The women who are so bitter and trying to fight males, they become strong but hard and callous. Mr Abraham wrote the women as well as the men in my opinion and a huge downside for me was the absence of the two main female characters in book 4.
In all, book 1 was 3.5 stars, books 2 and 3 are 4.0 stars, and book 4 is 4.5 stars for me. The nice thing about buying this series is you know it is done and complete. No waiting for 5 years for the next novel. That alone is worth something.