The Predator Culture by Fred Harrison
The endurance of poverty has its root in unfair land tenure. Fred Harrison calls this `The Culture of Pauperisation' demonstrating that power hierarchies are arranged in the interest of land appropriators. He borrows medical terminology, observing the state of dis-ease in societies as akin to a body suffering trauma. The world explorer/exploiters of the last 200-300 years described the civilizations they met as `primitive' rather than `normal'. Harrison claims that those societies had social systems which `were sophisticated mechanisms for integrating humans into their homelands'. He sees much of the violence in the world now as a legacy of the way these homelands were manipulated from then on. Incomers, through physical violence, by psychological means or by imposed law, subjugated the people, appropriated their land and its wealth, and wrecked the cultural and social fabric.
However Costa Rica, as seen by measures of: wealth (GDP); income distribution; wages and health outcomes has, over the past 50 years, been steadily outstripping neighbouring countries. It has no source of oil or valuable minerals as an obvious reason for this, but Harrison points to the availability of land and the way land taxation was adopted early on to pay for the public resources. These `enshrined the spirit of enterprise and liberty'.
Rwanda and Zimbabwe were more typical. Genocide in Rwanda on the scale of the Belgian colonial adventure in 1885 was a new phenomenon to Africa. Whilst reviewing the book, I noted current newspaper accounts of modern day Rwanda, none of which referred back more than 20 years. However there is a scheme in operation (reported in the Financial Times 22 Oct 2009) where 7.9 m plots of land are being surveyed prior to confirming ownership. But will this resolve cases where land was misappropriated some generations back? Harrison advocates that Truth & Reconciliation Commissions need to take a longer colonial-historic view. Maybe then there is hope that many running sores of injustice worldwide - potential causes of violence - might be resolved. He sees the US's $7.5bn aid for roads, etc, for Pakistan, as likely to be counter-productive to peace. It is likely to exacerbate the conflict between that country's own `predators' and `producers' and drive the poor further into extremism.
Sadness and frustration is induced by The Predator Culture. Which nations have seen the land tenure issue as the fundamental way of countering the culture of pauperisation? Unless we understand and act on Harrison's diagnosis, the perpetuation of disadvantaged generations will continue the dis-ease of injustice and unfairness, however `civilised' we think a culture is. This is a very important book. An excellent index, (but see the unindexed pages vii, 11 and 53 for banking/credit references for what was behind the land purchasing). Read The Predator Culture and gain insight for solutions to troubles in distant lands, as well as in your own. Let us hope Heads of State, Finance Ministers and Foreign Secretaries everywhere are told about this book.
The reviewer has no financial interest in the sales of this book. A copy was provided for review.