I'm not sure what it is that is missing from this book - passion perhaps, or the feeling that Johnson is reined in somehow by his protagonist, Mike Reed. It is a very adult, very world-weary book concerning a man who has never recovered from the death of his wife and daughter, four years ago, in a traffic accident. The most affecting moment in the book for me is when he is remembering the moment that they set off in an elderly neighbour's car and Mike leaned in at the window meaning to tell him to take the gravel track (the weather is icy and the neighbour is not a steady driver) into town, but in the end says something else, distracted by the neighbour.
Reed is an academic, having worked in Washington for a Senator for several years previous to getting a track post as a History Professor. He doesn't get tenure, but isn't bothered. To be frank, nothing much bothers him since he lost his family. The scenes where he is at various meetings and get-togethers don't resonate with much beyond boredom. He is fascinated however by a painting by an African American slave, in one of the halls of the college and he makes time to stand looking at this (abstract) painting, observed by the (African American) security guard whose job it is to patrol the gallery. He is also fascinated by the skating pond used by the students and the patterns they make, all going round one way. These two abstract fascinations seem linked by the flaws in the patterns made, rather than anything else, but their significance is not overtly linked in his mind.
Nothing much seems to happen until he becomes aware of a female student, a wild character called Flower who gives demonstrations of shaving her pudenda, plays the cello (not very well) and almost always wins the amateur stripping competitions held at a nearby roadhouse. She has a stash of envelopes that she keeps, in each of which is a sentence written by a friend or acquaintance, but she refuses to share these with him and he leaves. This is, fittingly, more or less where the book ends, in lack of (dreaded cliché) closure, rather than any kind of new beginning.
The book has no revelations to offer, Flower is just a blip in Reed's unconnected life. Johnson's use of dialogue is faultless, though his writing contains little of the deeply felt energy I've experienced in all his other books, making the novel seem soggy, affectless and somehow compromised. I couldn't identify with the main character and there was little else to grasp in this wavering, unsatisfying novel. I very much wanted to like it, and I was always fully engaged by the skilful writing, waiting for the iron to strike. But, this time, for me, he missed the anvil every time.