I have to say that having looked forward to this album I was a touch disappointed. Ok, there's no doubt that Jon Anderson's voice is back to what it should be after a terrible illness and it's great to hear him singing on a new record. The issues for me are that I would have liked to hear more vocal harmonies along with some acoustic guitar and some percussion to really lift the tracks on offer.
Rick Wakeman's keyboards are a bit of a let down too. There's not enough swirl and flair in his playing, so much so that although he plays beautifully at times, his performances are a bit on the dull side by his own considerably high standards.
The songs are a bit too twee for my taste. The problem with Jon Anderson is that if you let him loose and put him in charge of all the lyrics, you know that there's going to be plenty of 'love is everything' sugar and honey coated goodness and buddhist style philosophising, which I find highly pretentious. In the past, there's always been someone like Steve Howe, Chris Squire or Trevor Rabin on hand to reign him in. Not here.
That's not to say that there aren't some excellent tunes on offer. 'The Living Tree' parts 1 and 2 are wonderfully melodic and should point to the direction of the album.
'24/23/11' is a highly thought provoking song about war from a soldier's perspective and 'Forever' is a gorgeous ballad sung quite beautifully by Anderson.
I'm afraid that the rest is fairly 'in one ear and out the other' fare that never quite catches fire.
I was expecting an album along the lines of the first Jon and Vangelis album, an album that would be lyrically wistful and romantic in places, but with some fantasy and cosmic imagery thrown in.
Musically I expected lush, dreamy keyboards with loads of classical chops along with bags of acoustic guitar and exotic percussion with those instantly recognisable soaring vocal harmonies to give the music real majesty, drama and power.
The fact that 'The Living Tree' didn't deliver what I envisaged, considering the traditions of the two artists concerned left me feeling a little short changed and a little empty inside despite one or two highlights.