I was quite sceptical about this book, but I love Tolkien’s work and I was intrigued to know more about the books and other works that influenced him. I’m not a scholar and I don’t know how this work would be received by some of the more academic audiences that perhaps it seeks to reach. I found it fascinating, and extremely accessible. However, more than that, the book’s really broadened my horizons, I’ll never be a Tolkien Scholar but this work’s made me think and at the same time given me a enormously satisfying read. Thanks.