"The Inheritance," a new British mystery/courtroom drama/thriller by Simon Tolkien, whom the Los Angeles Times has described as "half Christie and half Grisham," gives us the tale of the murder of John Cade, Colonel Cade during his war hero World War II years; now an honored Professor Cade at England's prestigious Oxford University. The don is found dead in his locked study; circumstantial evidence weighs heavy against his son Stephen, who soon ("The Inheritance" is set in the 1950's, when the United Kingdom still hanged those convicted of murder), finds himself on trial for his life in the Old Bailey, London's famous old courthouse. However, there were five other people in the Cade manor that night, and Detective Inspector William Trave of the Oxford and Midland CID, who had initially gathered the evidence that put Stephen on trial, is now, rather late in the day, having misgivings as to his part in building this case. He is revisiting the alibis and backgrounds of the others in the house; he will find and unravel a thread that goes back to the Professor's WWII service in France.
This is a pretty good thriller, it kept me turning the pages, and I liked it. England of the 1950's is well-rendered, as is the Oxford area, its flora and fauna, and the speech of its people. London is also well-rendered. The dialog, narrative and descriptive writing all satisfied me. Characters struck me as unusually sturdy and well-drawn for an entertainment of this type. The courtroom scenes may not have the snap of master Grisham, but they kept my attention fixed on the plight of poor Stephen. The plot is, of course, an artificial construct - aren't they all, come to thrillers--and rarely has there been an English book with so many French, and/or Catholics running about, the better to throw dust in the reader's eye. Still, I was able to pick out the villain by pure process of elimination, as many other mystery fans may well be able to do. The villain is, in fact, a fairly classic Agatha Christie villain, in terms of looks, intelligence, social situation, and behavior, even unto taking the last two chapters to "'splain" it all at length; something that, by the by, hasn't been considered a good way to end a mystery at least since Christie's day.
"The Inheritance" follows on the highly-lauded heels of
Final Witness (2002), the writer's first fictional effort. Simon Tolkien was a successful barrister in London who specialized in criminal justice, before moving himself, his wife, and two children to California. He is the grandson of the world-famous J.R.R. Tolkien, an Oxford don for nearly 40 years, and the author of the fantasy masterpieces
The Hobbit, and
The Lord of the Rings (3 Book Box set). On the basis of his current effort, I'd say Simon's work is well-enough done that it would be published no matter what his last name was.