Leagues O'Toole is a self-confessed fan of Planxty and makes no attempt to conceal his passion for their music. So one might be forgiven for expecting The Humours of Planxty to be a fawning, sugar-coated love letter to a bunch of ageing folkies. Thankfully, this is not the case.
O'Toole adopts a self-effacing approach in putting together the fascinating story of the most important musical outfit, bar none, to emerge from Ireland. He allows each of the four principal group members to tell his own story. And they do so in an intelligent and reflective way, laying bare their mistakes and weaknesses, as well as giving us unique insights into their music-making.
But this is more than a history of Planxty. It is an invaluable account of the revival of Irish traditional music from the time when it was seen as a quaint relic of a forgotten past, kept alive by a few determined geniuses, such as Seamus Ennis and Willie Clancy. The book is filled with wonderful anecdotes and portraits of the various men and women whose musical lives intersected with Planxty. What comes across is the sheer joy all of them experience in playing and hearing this wonderful ancient music.
But, of course, the focus is on Planxty, each of whose four founding members seems to eat, sleep, and breathe Irish music. Together they made magic, (although not much money it appears). And Leagues O'Toole has done them justice in this biography. More than that, his quietly determined efforts to tell the Planxty story led to the group reforming after 20 years and playing at a series of sold-out concerts in Dublin. The DVD released later shows that, if anything, the passage of time has brought them to an even higher musical plane than they occupied in their heyday. Their individual virtuosity, their ensemble playing, and the complementary singing of Irvine and Moore suggests a group at its peak.
But there is one quibble. If ever a book cried out for a comprehensive index, this is it. Hopefully the publishers will rise to the occasion for the next edition, and merit that fifth star.