L.C.Tyler's The Herring-Seller's Apprentice, his debut novel, was a splendidly witty affair. It attracted a good deal of well-deserved attention, introducing as it did two very entertaining characters, unsuccessful crime writer Ethelred Tressider and his long-suffering agent Elsie Thirkettle, in a story which paid agreeable homage to the Golden Age mystery. There was a freshness about the story and its telling that lifted it well above run of the mill pastiche. So I approached Tyler's fourth and latest novel, and his third featuring Ethelred and Elsie, with much enthusiasm. Happily, it lived up to expectations. As the title suggests, we are in Golden Age territory. In classic fashion, Ethelred's old friend Sir Robert Muntham is found dead in the library of Muntham Court, after a dinner attended by Ethelred, Elsie, and a host of people who had reason to wish Sir Robert harm. The present day narrative is accompanied by extracts from one of Ethelred's historical mysteries, featuring Chaucer's sidekick Master Thomas, investigating a crime which has curious parallels with the case of Sir Robert. Tyler manages, therefore, to poke fun at two different kinds of detective story in the course of one novel. There are plenty of jokes, as well as a witty finale, and if you like intelligent, light-hearted mysteries, with not a sadistic serial killer in sight, this will be right up your street.
Reviewed by Martin Edwards - author of the highly acclaimed Harry Devlin Mysteries)