The main set up for the book is based around the genuine documented existence of an elite Highland guard tasked to protect Robert Bruce during his quest to free Scotland from English rule. Bruce wants the throne back from Edward I (the hammer of Scotland) and has sought out the best of the best of the best that Scotland has to offer to act as his muscle, protection, spies and anything else he might need them for.
This sounds promising doesn't it? However, it all felt very much like mere background information to what was essentially a somewhat dull and lacklustre love story. There was very little in the way of battles or action scenes. None in fact, that I can recall. So if your reading the synopsis hoping to find some kind of epic love story set during a famous historical battle, something along the lines of Jamie and Claire from the Outlander series, which was set around the battle of Culloden, you're going to be epically disappointed. As was I.
Although I can't deny McCarty did her research and that I found a lot of it very interesting. I particularly enjoyed the little anecdotal story of Robert the Bruce and the determined spider right at the beginning of the book, which inspired him during one of his darkest hours and is also apparently where the saying "If at first you don't succeed, try, try and try again" came from.
Basically, I think the Elite guard angle only served to set up Eric's status as a "warrior" type, and therefore making him appear that much more swoonworthy in the eyes of the reader. And he was swoonworthy, I suppose. Looks-wise anyway. I'm just not sure I like the fact that he was a bit of a "player", or that I believe Ellie would ever really tame him, no matter what he says to the contrary.
The female character, Lady Eleanor (Ellie) Deberg, was supposed to be this feisty, spirited lass. The first one ever to stand up to Eric or to tell him no, and therefore, naturally, the only one he wants...
*eye roll*
If you count challenging him as insisting on washing all of his men's clothes until her hands bleed, against his orders, as feisty and spirited, then I guess you could be right. It didn't really work for me though.
I did enjoy the scenery of this book, however. The settings of Ireland and Scotland were vivid and picturesque, and I could almost feel the wind in my hair and the bracing cold of the Irish sea around my ankles. And, as mentioned, the historical details were quite a bit more detailed than some other Historical Romance authors bother to provide.
The pacing was...gentle, to put it kindly. Another word I could use would be "slow", but as it seemed like a deliberate choice by the author not to make this the battle-filled, high action read I was hoping for, I will use the former. There was often not a lot happening other than one character thinking about the other. Or trying not to.
Basically, to sum up, it was a well written book, in an interesting time and setting, with a love story that almost made it. But it was just a bit too dull for me. In a book with a Highland guard I want to see someone getting their ass handed to them, not a pile of washing.