This novel about the social climbing daughter of a butler is quite unlike any other novel by Thomas Hardy that I have read - and I've read most of them.
For a start, the subtitle is "A Comedy in Chapters". Although I accept that there is humour in some of Hardy's works, "comedy" is not the first word that springs to mind when you think of Thomas Hardy.
Then, after opening chapters set in Hardy's beloved Wessex, the central part of the book is set in London. Although Hardy worked in London for a while, it is clear that he had little love for the place and the descriptions of locations are perfunctory. It is when the action returns to Wessex that for me it really came to life. There is an exciting description of a ship caught in a storm off Knollsea (Swanage) and an amusing account of a visit to Corvsgate (Corfe) Castle. I found myself really caring about which of the four suitors Ethelbertha would end up with and there are a couple of twists before the end.
If it has been possible to award 3 1/2 stars I would have done so. I quite liked the novel but I didn't love it in the way that I love "Far From the Madding Crowd" or "The Return of the Native" and I certainly didn't feel the catharsis that I did when I read "Jude The Obscure".