James Inverne is an outstanding writer. His boundless enthusiasm for the subject comes across in this highly readable pocket guide to stage musicals.
Sensibly laid out, we are first treated to a personal exposition on the history of the stage musical, before the author picks 100 of the best. Of course, with so many to choose from, you'll have plenty of fun disagreeing with his choices. "Annie," "The Fantasticks" and "Grand Hotel" are absent, to name but three, yet included are those on the opera / musical borderline like "Candide."
Each selection is given an introduction, trivia spot, synopsis and `recommended recording' treatment. Occasionally the balance in length between them has a reader thinking, "I'd like to know more about..., so why did he discuss...?" but each is still informative enough that your CD collection will grow exponentially after reading.
Insightful essays on matters musical follow. The writer's own top 10 will obviously please nobody but himself; rightly so, and it is just a pleasure to learn far more about his own tastes. His musings on "Musicals Go To The Opera" seem, to my own (probably philistine) ear, to rather over-complicate the issue. It's pretty simple; when hearing a musical theatre diva in full belt, I can distinguish every word and think "wow!" An opera singer in full vocal exposition simply induces a headache within minutes.
Wrapping up the book is Mr Inverne's choice of 10 musical flops. Again his list will spark huge debate, with such treasures-that-deserve-to-be-buried as "Bernadette," "A Doll's Life," "Jeeves" and "Kelly" missing. Still, it leaves plenty of room for a sequel.
The only failure of this book is in its editing. In several places an uneducated pen has cut important detail from the text, leaving a howler behind. The former is occasionally to the detriment of show descriptions; the latter will irritate musical theatre buffs, and require quiz compliers to cross-check details.
Still, this a must for all musical theatre fans wishing to learn a little more about them; particularly assisting newcomers as an introduction to this strange and wonderful world.