'The Essence of the Thing' is a perfectly crafted account of a relationship break-up in which every word of dialogue and every development in the plot ring absolutely true. The plot is straight-forward: Nicola comes home after popping out to buy some cigarettes and her partner Jonathan, with whom she co-habits, informs her that he wants to break-up. In short, punchy chapters Madeleine St John then skillfully sets out the events that led to the pronouncement that takes so Nicola completely by shock, and the aftermath of Jonathan's unilateral decision for both parties.
Although the novel focuses more on Nicola, St John does allow Jonathan to explain the reasoning behind his decision, and there is a total absence of authorial judgment throughout the novel on the actions of the characters. This objectivity is largely achieved by allowing the characters to tell their own story through large exchanges of dialogue. And what dialogue! St John has an incredible ear, convincingly relying on dialogue both to develop the storyline and to flesh out the characters of the troubled couple, their friends and parents.
Despite the sadness obviously inherent in the storyline, the mood of the novel is elevated by the warmth and humanity demonstrated by many of the characters, particularly towards Nicola. Furthermore, 'The Essence of the Thing' contains generous doses of humour including lively banter from Nicola's friends to cheer her up; sparkling marital exchanges between Nicola's friend Susannah and her loving husband Geoffrey; and the delightful observations of their wonder child, Guy.
Thank you so much to the judges for the 1997 Booker Prize for short-listing 'The Essence of the Thing', without which it is unlikely to have come to my attention. Booker-nominated novels, including winners, over the award's 37-year history have met fates ranging from obscurity and life in remainder bins through to near universal critical acclaim and time at the top of best-seller lists. This literary gem deserves to be widely read, so please, please track it down and help ensure that it realises its rightful destiny.