As fiction, this is first-rate, with vivid scenes and excellent characterization of the Philippines and Tokyo in the closing months of World War II. As history it is flawed by numerous errors, which will not be noticed by most readers but grate on my own personal experiences as long-time resident of the Philippines, where from 1941 until February 1945 I a civilian POW; then an Associated Press war correspondent in devastated Manila, later covering the war crimes trials of Yamashita and Homma. For example, Webb discusses only military POWs, ignoring the 7500 American and other Allied civilian men, women and children who remained alive for liberation in February 1945 and even then confuses prison camps. He provides a location for Yamashita's surrender across two major mountain ranges from the actual site. It was the Roosevelt administration that prodded him to provide details on how he planned to try Japanese war criminals. Even historical fiction needs to get the background details right.