I found this memoir beautifully written and, in many ways, a continous challenge to my own feelings and beliefs. It is a book that I think will evoke a certain amount of resistance, particularly in his views concerning the unnaturalness of fidelity in gay men. And that is why I liked it so much - the author is very unashamedly honest and puts into words the questions with which many of us struggle for answers. I especially liked his essay, "Paternities", and how fatherhood (the recognition of his own father's influence as well as his influence on his "son")continues to redefine an identity that I think so many gay men assume is fixed.
The book is personally challenging, persuasive, honest and totally non-judgemental. He writes with the somewhat detached manner of a critical and curious observer, but the words really become like a song that seem to transcend a "gay" identity and illuminates a broader "male" identity in all its flattering as well as unflattering aspects.
I definitely recommend this book as a "must read". In my estimation, it joins the ranks of Paul Monette's "Becoming a Man" as innovative, honest reflection, both men who tell it like it is for them and provide us with self-revelations along the way.