Ellis Peters brings us an old but always compelling and emotional story - two brothers, one well loved, the other one not so well. The emotions reflected in this book are so deep that it can move you to tears and, at the same time, the suspense about the murder and which of the two brothers did it is and mounting throughout the book. Time is crucial and we are given all the clues but in the end we just want the devil's novice to return to his home, father and choose rightly between two women, one of them his brother's bride. This book has everything but love between father and son, between brothers, between man and woman is the point and makes it a thrilling read.