One doesn't need to be struggling with cancer to ask many of the same questions as Bruce Feiler. All of us are just one tragedy away from leaving our children without the influence of their mother or father. I've thought of this from time to time, and wondered if the cobbled-together collections of my personal writing, photographs, and the memories of my other family members and friends would really communicate who I am to any of my offspring. These aren't morbid questions, but an examination of how to leave a child a legacy of emotional fortitude and knowledge, not just the burdens of going through the rest of their life fatherless.
Bruce Feiler addresses these questions with painful honesty. In the midst of his personal tragedy, being diagnosed with a cancerous tumor in his leg, he looks for a way to give his twin daughters the knowledge of the values most important to him should the worst happen. By assembling a group of men who know and love him and his family to be part-time father's to his girls. The most impressive thing about this plan is that despite his cancer, he looks outside himself and realizes that the needs of his girls are even more important than his own. That is what being a father is all about, and I deeply appreciated his love and care for his family. There were moments in the book that made me tear up--and I am not the 'crying kind.'
However, the book itself is less about the council of dads that Bruce assembles than it is a narrative of his journey through his battle with cancer. The book is arranged into alternating chapters of letters to his family and friends about the process of fighting cancer and family life, and chapters describing the men whom he has selected to be part of the council. The descriptions of each man are poignant, if narrow. I would have appreciated more detail on each, more detail on why he chose them, and a better overall view of what specifically he wanted his daughters to know, beyond "I loved you deeply." Much of that does get communicated through the book, but it would have been nice to see it captured as part of the narrative about the council members themselves.
A quick read at around 200 pages, this isn't a book on fighting cancer, nor a book on assembling a council of dads. It's really a exposition on what it is to realize your own mortality. Many lesser men and women let that realization turn them into self-absorbed or angry people. Bruce is instead honest about his own suffering, but also continually looking to his family's needs first. The impression I left with was that he was truly a lovely person and an amazing father. I wish him all the best and pray that the remainder of his life will be cancer free.
4/5 Stars.