When I read The Book of Lies by Mary Horlock earlier this month, it sparked my interest in the subject of the Nazi occupation of Guernsey during WW2, so I was very keen to continue this theme with Margaret Leroy's latest book.
Vivienne de la Mere's marriage is cold and unloving, and with her husband Eugene off fighting for the allies and food and other supplies becoming scarce, she is vulnerable to the kindness and generosity shown to her family by the German officers who move into the abandoned house next door. As her relationship with one of them develops, Vivienne's life becomes one of secrets and deception as she lies to her family and friends about where the gifts of chocolate and other luxuries came from. In return, Vivienne (always a bit of an outsider as she was born on the mainland) is regarded with suspicion by some of the islanders who observe her `fraternising' with the enemy.
This isn't a heavy, in-depth look at the depravations suffered by the people of Guernsey during the occupation, but it does deal with some serious issues such as the appalling treatment of the 'slave' workers who were put to work on the island, including Jewish and Russian prisoners. Most people's reaction at the thought of a woman becoming romantically involved with a German officer during WW2 would be "How could she?" but, as this book demonstrates, nothing is ever black and white. I guess it's reasonable to assume that people weren't aware of the full extent of the horrific acts carried out by the Nazis until after the war (and certainly not the residents of Guernsey who were effectively cut off from the outside world) and not all German soldiers were involved in the atrocities committed in their name. This book certainly gave me food for thought and I think it would spark an interesting debate at a book group meeting.
Just one niggle - the first person/present tense narration jarred a bit and, although I became more accustomed to it as the story progressed, I do think this story could have been more convincingly told in the past tense.