As a Clash fan who has read both editions of Gray's opus (Last Gang in Town being the first), I think I prefer the first because it offers a broader sweep of the band and the context in which they existed. This revised edition is essential reading for diehard fans - every song, every gig (almost!) is detailed to the point of obsession, which will delight anoraks, but it lacks the intimate touch. There's a lot on the early background of the various members, but little on the "where are they now" front... The book seems to finish rather abruptly, with only the briefest update on the Clash since the split. And, being a gossipy type, it would have been interesting to have more on their personal lives. It's a hefty read for anyone but probably the most authoritative and objective account of the most influential band of the modern era. Perhaps the two books would have worked better as two separate editions, with the second as a sequel, as there is so much material. Some people around the Clash were only touched on briefly, when they were clearly pivotal in the Clash entourage, so Johnny Green's biog is an essential companion, for example.