A worthy imitator of McDonald Fraser's Flashman series, in both content and style, and obviously aimed at that readership, even to the device of publishing a series of discovered memoirs. Not (yet) as good as GMF at his best, but already better than him at his worst.
An excellent choice of a flawed hero, taken from historical fiction, with the clear intention of more books to come - there are passing references to other episodes in the character's life. The story is well written, the characters well defined, with enough period feel to set the scene without it becoming overwhelming, and left me wanting to learn more about the French Revolution and the characters behind it - always a good sign!
If anything, the only disappointment was the (short) explanation of Flashman's parentage. It seemed a clumsy insert and out of context, given that the book is about Carton's exploits in revolutionary France, 20 years before Harry's birth. It was probably included just to justify the reference on the cover that made me buy the book in the first place, so that we fans did not feel cheated - but it might have been sufficient to make some passing reference and expand more in a subsequent book, as the book stands on its own merits.
I will be looking out for the next set of chronicles.