Big Red and Old Red Amlingmeyer return for their third adventure in this excellent mystery series by Steve Hockensmith. This time the story picks up where the previous novel left off, with our heroes attempting to make a living, "detectivin' and deducifyin'" in 1893 San Francisco and finding themselves embroiled in the middle of a mystery in Chinatown, caught between the Tongs, the local Civic Leaders, the Police and Big Red's inability to keep his headwear safe.
Hockensmith paints 19th Century San Francisco vividly, with Chinatown being a place far removed from todays tourist centre. A place both alien and exotic right in the middle of a bustling American city. It is one of the books many strengths, and the series as a whole, that the Amlingmeyer's adventures take place in a different environment with each novel, from the plains of, "Holmes On The Range," to the railroads of, "On The Wrong Track," to Chinatown here in, "The Black Dove." It serves to keep the stories fresh, providing new sights and experiences for our heroes, thereby developing their characters along the way, preventing them from becoming repetetive and giving Hockensmith the opportunity to explore new environments, historical events and ideas with each story.
As ever, Big Red's narration provides wonderful humour and insight as the brother's attempt to solve the murder of their friend, Doc Chan, and deduce the whereabouts (and the, "whatsabouts") of the titular Black Dove. The brothers relationship is developed even further, with past events once again coming to light, and it is Hockensmith's writing of this relationship that makes the book so good. They may fight, argue and constantly engage in oneupmanship with each other, resulting in some truly hilarious asides, but there is real brotherly love and admiration in there too and it really does make the Amlingmeyer's leap off the page.
Of course, it helps to have a cracking mystery to solve, with last second escapes and derring-do (done only the way the Amlingmeyer's can with plenty of comedy and self-deprecating humour) and a whole cast of intriguing, well drawn characters for them to play off (along with much welcomed returning characters, adding a great, "ensemble," feel to the books), which this book has in droves (or should that be, "drovers?".... Apologies, a bit of Old Red's narrative style rubbing off on me there.....) as well as battles with deadly Tongs using only bric-a-brac, an encounter with a very dead scorpion and plenty of jokes involving the passing of wind (these ARE cowboys, remember!). And, as is becoming readily apparent in these novels, an encounter in a toilet that is hilarious in the extreme. Whether it's murder in the out-house in the first novel, attempted murder by snake in the second or what happens here, WC's are obviously a dangerous place where Big Red and Old Red are concerned.
Once again, Steve Hockensmith has provided a funny, exciting and intriguing murder mystery, taking the best traditions of Holmes (or, "The Man," as Old Red would have us call him) and giving them a delightful and unique twist. The only problem is he sets things up so wonderfully for their next adventure it's such a pity we are going to have to wait a year to read it.