As a 32 year old Beatle fan returning to watch this film this after 15 years or so I am a little less disappointed than I was when I first saw it. I feel this film gets better with age just as Help gets worse. I appreciate things about it that I just thought were a waste of footage before, really, and now like it for what it is. It was disappointing originally because there is no story to draw you in, the ad libing is not that funny or developed, it is rambling and very short. But then that said a lot about my rigid expectations. If one is more open minded and has other ways of seeing one can see that this film is partially successful.
I've never watched this under the influence of drugs but I can see how it would beautifully compliment such an experience with its colour and its peculiar and romantic incidents. And even without them, I enjoy the set pieces, I enjoy what people wear, the fact that this film mixes the old with young, the fact that this is more authentically 1967 than a big budget scripted film would have been. There are lots of little things going on that will make the movie worth re-visiting. It captures the faces of people who weren't glamorous but somehow people of their time. It gives you an insight into British culture. It would certainly appeal to an anthropologist. With a bit more encouragement it could have been great and it certainly sits alongside Hard Day's Night, Yellow Sub and Let It be nicely, because these films each do something unique, well. (Four out of five good film ain't bad and Help at least has great music.)
Alas, MMT it's a few minutes too short, I reckon. I so badly want to see more of what went on that trip. It's been mercilessly and I would guess unexpertly edited. I would bet any money that if we had all the footage they shot it could be re-cut and be much better but I've read that footage has gone, alas. So what if that missing footage is Lennon ripping the letters off the side of the bus? That would have been great. And needless to say the music is top notch.