...It's hard to sum up "The Dream Deferred" in a word or two. But whatever else it is, it is THE great South African political biography, a book that must be read by anyone interested in the history of the country. It is eloquent, fascinating and compulsively readable, in spite of its 800 pages.
The book succeeds in evoking the mystery and tragedy of Thabo Mbeki, a brilliant, failed man, groomed in exile to lead the ANC in power, yet ultimately brought down by...well, by WHAT exactly? By ego? A mania for power? Racial hyper-sensitivity? A lack of the common touch? The book doesn't answer the question. Its timing couldn't have been worse: conceived at the high point of Mbeki's power and published immediately prior to his downfall, "The Dream Deferred" lacks the benefit of hindsight and is too busy with high-concept "literary" themes like exile and homecoming to attend to "small" matters like utter political miscalculation. But even if it doesn't have the last word on Mbeki's career, the book raises great questions and is filled with arresting insights. It's highly recommended.
That said, readers looking for conventional political biography might be disappointed. The book is very much about Mbeki's life, not his times. It is high-brow journalism, not true scholarship. Just when the reader is expecting real history -- about the intricate negotiations to unban the ANC, say, or about the economic policies of post-apartheid South Africa -- the author backs off and delivers long meditations on Mbeki's tortured soul. Some of his interpretive gloss is profound, all of it is interesting -- even when it borders on pop-psychology -- but there is too much of it.