I got the Black Wallet case for my Samsung Galaxy S3 and i'm very happy with it. I read the reviews beforehand and wasn't sure what to expect but I just don't understand what the negative ones are talking about, unless they got the folio version which I have no experience of.
It is well made and looks good. I do wish the clasp for the handle was silver rather than gold but that's personal preference.
It fits perfectly, tight enough that the phone doesn't slip out of the case, but not so tight as to damage the phone as some people have said. And, yes, I have tested that by removing it a few times, no damage that I can see.
The closure tab slots through a loop. This is not challenging to do! Even when the phone is ringing, I can even do it one-handed so I don't understand that complaint at all!
The holes in the case and the plastic part that the phone sits in match the buttons/camera/flash perfectly. Nothing is obscured.
It's a great little case for the money, much cheaper and nicer than anything available in the shop when I got the phone.