Lady Morwenna of Caleron Castle is presented with a wounded man found outside her keep. He has been so badly beaten that no one recognizes him but he wears a ring bearing the family crest of her old lover. A man named Carrick, shown sketchily through a variety of flashbacks, who abandoned their affair and was later thought guilty of the murders of seven of his own family members. Morwenna is conflicted. If this beaten man is not Carrick then she could be sending an innocent man to face his executioner by notifying Carricks remaining kin. If it is Carrick, she is still conflicted because she believes herself to still be in love with him even though he treated her abominably. The author portrays this woman as a strong lead character and yet she allows Morwenna to be conflicted over a man who was, by all accounts according to flashbacks, a dirtbag? Where is the romance? The unconscious man stays pretty much unconscious or uncommunicative through most of the novel only to wake up have sex with Morwenna and then race off to find himself. Meanwhile, Morwenna spends the rest of her time dithering about what to do and chasing around after the mystery killer,called The Redeemer,who lurks around thinking lascivious thoughts and occasionally murdering expendable characters. In addition to these guys, Ms. Jackson then throws in several new characters at various inexplicable times to keep the reader from guessing the killer's identity. The entire book has an identity crisis. The relationship between the hero and heroine is never developed. They have so few actual interactions that you wonder how they can even know each other much less be in love. In fact, most of the characters are underdevelped due to the fact that there are so many of them haphazardly thrown in whenever the author wrote herself into a corner. It has so many plot twists that nothing ever comes together. In the end I was just saying pick a murderer already, any one will do! The real crime here is that in the end, Ms. Jackson leaves the story open for a sequel focused on Morwenna's sister,Bryanna, conveniently turned into a psychic and future heroine of another convoluted mystery/ romance/paranormal or maybe it will be a cookbook.....