I read quite a few novels (generally classics), but have not read a graphic novel in years. I picked up this one on the basis of Simmonds' artwork, but I found it a really entertaining read.
Simmonds draws, paints and inks very nicely. I like her style. Using a muted palette of blues and greens, accented with other colours here and there, she creates very pleasing pictures. She uses these to show action, while using prose to convey the thoughts of her characters. This works very well, giving some depth to what she shows us. Her main characters are distinctive and expressive, and mostly types that one can "get" immediately.
The story is, of course, a vague retelling of Far From The Madding Crowd, set in a modern English village. Simmonds is relentless in using her characters to make pointed comments about life in a village, often using these opinions to give her characters their essential attitudes and personalities. She reserves particular venom for rich weekenders from the city who, having descended upon and bought their way into such villages for their idyllic appearance, have turned what was a hard-working village into a mishmash of suburbia and weekend retreat. Her attack on these people made surprisingly satisfying reading, as I have seen this happen in my once-rural hometown. The story flags a little in parts, especially around the middle pages, as Simmonds presents some exposition that sets up the last part of the plot. Overall though, it was non-stop and rather sharp storytelling.
Simmonds' sense of humour, her artistic style, and her tremendous ability to combine words and pictures in an adult, thoughtful and entertaining way, make this a great page-turner. I know that many people scoff at graphic novels as juvenile and a bit of lightweight junk for the lazy, but that view misses the point of the graphic novel. One of the great things about them is that they get on with it - something a great many authors should learn to do. I enjoyed it a great deal, and have ordered more of her work.